Why we choose Make over Zapier (Make vs Zapier)?

Dash-avatar-img
發佈於PilotIT
更新於 發佈於 閱讀時間約 12 分鐘
raw-image

Last Updated:2023/Sep/10

Make vs Zapier (Make.com vs Zapier.com)

In today's fast-paced digital landscape, automation and workflow optimization are essential for businesses and individuals alike.

Zapier and Make.com both offer unique solutions to help users streamline repetitive tasks and boost productivity.

If you wanna see first-hand on how Make and Zapier can streamline data automation, you can directly register free accounts both at Make and Zapier.

Register a free account at Make.com
https://www.make.com

Register a free account at Zapier
https://zapier.com/

For people still wondering which platform is better for the automation tasks, we would like to share our experience in choosing between Make and Zapier.

Although we finally adopt Make as our primary tool for data automation, it does not imply Make is absolutely superior in every aspect.

Readers should make their own judgements based on the business needs and task requirements in choosing the automation platform.


Limitations of Free Account

According to Zapier's pricing plan (https://zapier.com/app/pricing), the free account can creat only "single-step" zaps.

This "single-step" restriction basically means a zap could perform only one action.

Unfortunately, our data automation project requires several actions to complete the required job such as writing data to Google Sheet and passing extra infomation to Excel.

The free account of Zapier does not allow us to perform two actions in one zap.

In the following zap, we try to export data from HubSpot to Google Sheet.

raw-image

After passing the data to Google Sheet, we intend to synchronize the data with Excel in OneDrive.

However, the free account of Zapier does not allow us to add an extra action to synchronize with an Excel file.

Without actually trying whether a zap will work or not, how are we supposed to believe that Zapier can help us get the job done?

In contrast, the free account of Make.com does not have any restriction on the number of "actions" in its free account.

Make.com calls each automation workflow as a "scenario".

In each scenario, we could add several actions to complete our automation task.

In the following screenshot, we create a scenario in Make.com to export data from HubSpot to Google Sheet and Excel.

raw-image

This scenario involves two actions (writing data to Google Sheet and Excel). Such a design is not allowed in the free account of Zapier.

Webhook in Zapier requires Premium

For engineers working on data synchronization on the web, webhooks are powerful tools in data automation over the web.

If you job is heavily related to data synchronization over the Internet, inevitably there will be situations in which webhooks become an indispensable option in synchronizing the data. Sometimes, webhooks may even be the only option in data synchronization.

On one occassion, we try to use "webhooks" in Zapier and bump into the following screen:

raw-image

Ouch, the webhook app in Zapier is a "premium" feature, which is NOT available for free accounts.

Now again, how can we trust Zapier to get the job done "without" even trying the webhooks in the first place.

In contrast, Make allows us to use webhooks in the free account so that we can truly validate the automation workflow actually works.

See the following screenshot in which we rely on a webhook to export data from HubSpot to Google Sheet.

raw-image

Zapier Misses the Custom Fields from HubSpot

When designing one zap in Zapier to access the data from HubSpot, we encounter a mysterious issue in which all custom fields of HubSpot display "No data".

After searching for a solution on the web, we read the following webpage discussed in Zapier community.

https://community.zapier.com/troubleshooting-99/hubspot-to-sheets-missing-data-20664

The preceding webpage illustrates our problem in which standard default fields pass through while all custom fields are missing.

This is truly a deal breaker for us since our data synchronization will utterly fail without fetching these custom fields from HubSpot.

In the end, we turn to Make.com and successfully access the HubSpot data with all custom fields inside.

Connecting with HubSpot from Make.com

Connecting with HubSpot from Make.com

Connecting with HubSpot from Make.com is a breeze for us to set up.

No more juggling with tedious settings. Make.com really makes it straightforward to design an automation workflow.

Conclusions

Very few software or applications are perfect in this world. Likewise, neither Make or Zapier is perfect either.

We choose Make thanks to its easy connection with HubSpot and a rather generous policy for free accounts to try all features.

Hope our experience may help some engineers in choosing the appropriate automation platform for their jobs.

Register a free account at Make.com
https://www.make.com

Register a free account at Zapier
https://zapier.com/


留言
avatar-img
留言分享你的想法!
avatar-img
Dash的沙龍
7會員
118內容數
當個「聰明」的消費者,懂得省錢,也懂得省時間,並兼顧使用體驗
你可能也想看
Thumbnail
孩子寫功課時瞇眼?小心近視!這款喜光全光譜TIONE⁺光健康智慧檯燈,獲眼科院長推薦,網路好評不斷!全光譜LED、180cm大照明範圍、5段亮度及色溫調整、350度萬向旋轉,讓孩子學習更舒適、保護眼睛!
Thumbnail
孩子寫功課時瞇眼?小心近視!這款喜光全光譜TIONE⁺光健康智慧檯燈,獲眼科院長推薦,網路好評不斷!全光譜LED、180cm大照明範圍、5段亮度及色溫調整、350度萬向旋轉,讓孩子學習更舒適、保護眼睛!
Thumbnail
創作者營運專員/經理(Operations Specialist/Manager)將負責對平台成長及收入至關重要的 Partnership 夥伴創作者開發及營運。你將發揮對知識與內容變現、影響力變現的精準判斷力,找到你心中的潛力新星或有聲量的中大型創作者加入 vocus。
Thumbnail
創作者營運專員/經理(Operations Specialist/Manager)將負責對平台成長及收入至關重要的 Partnership 夥伴創作者開發及營運。你將發揮對知識與內容變現、影響力變現的精準判斷力,找到你心中的潛力新星或有聲量的中大型創作者加入 vocus。
Thumbnail
透過 Webhook 與 No Code 自動化工具,在 SurveyCake 問卷填答後,自動寄個人化信件。全程無需寫程式,即可自動帶入問卷特定填答內容,還可與 Google Sheets 結合,帶入不重複專屬序號至信件中,讓行銷應用更完整!幫助你節省人工成本,提高資料準確性、通知即時性和工作效率
Thumbnail
透過 Webhook 與 No Code 自動化工具,在 SurveyCake 問卷填答後,自動寄個人化信件。全程無需寫程式,即可自動帶入問卷特定填答內容,還可與 Google Sheets 結合,帶入不重複專屬序號至信件中,讓行銷應用更完整!幫助你節省人工成本,提高資料準確性、通知即時性和工作效率
Thumbnail
最近剛好分配一個需求,要批次更新一些基礎設定資料,而新系統基礎設定資料都統一由別的團隊維護在Google Sheet 上,一開始是要我寫 Laravel Seeder 塞資料表,後來發現也太多數據要批次更新了,數據要對到何時何年,乾脆來研究串 Google Sheet API 整批塞入在對總行數就好
Thumbnail
最近剛好分配一個需求,要批次更新一些基礎設定資料,而新系統基礎設定資料都統一由別的團隊維護在Google Sheet 上,一開始是要我寫 Laravel Seeder 塞資料表,後來發現也太多數據要批次更新了,數據要對到何時何年,乾脆來研究串 Google Sheet API 整批塞入在對總行數就好
Thumbnail
Make 提供了一個便捷的方式,讓你可以輕鬆地串聯不同的程式,使得工作和生活流程更加順暢。在這篇教學中,我們將探討如何透過 Make 將 Google Forms 與 Notion 整合,讓你能直接將表單回應的內容儲存至 Notion 資料庫中,省去了一一手動複製貼上的繁瑣步驟,節省了大量時間。
Thumbnail
Make 提供了一個便捷的方式,讓你可以輕鬆地串聯不同的程式,使得工作和生活流程更加順暢。在這篇教學中,我們將探討如何透過 Make 將 Google Forms 與 Notion 整合,讓你能直接將表單回應的內容儲存至 Notion 資料庫中,省去了一一手動複製貼上的繁瑣步驟,節省了大量時間。
Thumbnail
Last Updated:2023/Sep/10 Make vs Zapier (Make.com vs Zapier.com) In today's fast-paced digital landscape, automation and workflow optimization are e
Thumbnail
Last Updated:2023/Sep/10 Make vs Zapier (Make.com vs Zapier.com) In today's fast-paced digital landscape, automation and workflow optimization are e
Thumbnail
n8n 提供近 400 種常見應用程式的串接,並具備友善的 UI 介面和彈性設定、高度彈性能夠自行建構、疊加程式碼,打破現有模組的限制,實現更多可能性。也提供開源免費版本,讓你在自己主機上建置自動化系統,無限制地創建流程。不論你是初學者還是有技術背景的使用者,n8n 給予更多彈性自由來提高工作效率。
Thumbnail
n8n 提供近 400 種常見應用程式的串接,並具備友善的 UI 介面和彈性設定、高度彈性能夠自行建構、疊加程式碼,打破現有模組的限制,實現更多可能性。也提供開源免費版本,讓你在自己主機上建置自動化系統,無限制地創建流程。不論你是初學者還是有技術背景的使用者,n8n 給予更多彈性自由來提高工作效率。
Thumbnail
Make 是一個專為建立自動化流程的 NoCode 工具,支援以視覺化方式自由設計、拖曳串聯上千種應用程式、服務,可說是數位工具界的膠水,讓人輕鬆無痛打造自動化流程!提供 5,000+ 常用自動化工作流程範本可以輕鬆套用,跨應用程式間的資料同步、觸發行動,不再手動處理,交給自動化完成!
Thumbnail
Make 是一個專為建立自動化流程的 NoCode 工具,支援以視覺化方式自由設計、拖曳串聯上千種應用程式、服務,可說是數位工具界的膠水,讓人輕鬆無痛打造自動化流程!提供 5,000+ 常用自動化工作流程範本可以輕鬆套用,跨應用程式間的資料同步、觸發行動,不再手動處理,交給自動化完成!
Thumbnail
工作日常中 Gmail 信箱總伴隨著海量信件與附件往返,有時候附件收到後都要再逐一上傳到公司內部雲端資料夾,或手動儲存到個人的雲端硬碟,方便未來查找與協作。現在只要 Gmail 信箱的信件包含附檔,NoCode 幫你自動同步儲存至 Google 雲端硬碟資料夾建檔,再也不用手動儲存或擔心遺忘建檔啦!
Thumbnail
工作日常中 Gmail 信箱總伴隨著海量信件與附件往返,有時候附件收到後都要再逐一上傳到公司內部雲端資料夾,或手動儲存到個人的雲端硬碟,方便未來查找與協作。現在只要 Gmail 信箱的信件包含附檔,NoCode 幫你自動同步儲存至 Google 雲端硬碟資料夾建檔,再也不用手動儲存或擔心遺忘建檔啦!
Thumbnail
無法解決雙向同步 Notion 與 Google 日曆的問題嗎?透過 NoCode 自動化工具來解決吧!未來只要在 Notion 新增一筆任務項目,NoCode 幫你自動同步建立 Google 日曆行程;若在 Google 日曆上編輯、刪除行程,也會自動更新 Notion 的任務項目資訊哦!
Thumbnail
無法解決雙向同步 Notion 與 Google 日曆的問題嗎?透過 NoCode 自動化工具來解決吧!未來只要在 Notion 新增一筆任務項目,NoCode 幫你自動同步建立 Google 日曆行程;若在 Google 日曆上編輯、刪除行程,也會自動更新 Notion 的任務項目資訊哦!
Thumbnail
如何透過 Google Sheet (試算表) 與 Google Doc (文件) 自動化文件套版流程?不需要寫任何程式,就可以完成自動化文件套版流程的串接設定,之後也不用再手動一一複製貼上製作文件,只要輸入一筆或多筆 Google Sheet 資料,文件套版就交給 NoCode 自動化完成吧!
Thumbnail
如何透過 Google Sheet (試算表) 與 Google Doc (文件) 自動化文件套版流程?不需要寫任何程式,就可以完成自動化文件套版流程的串接設定,之後也不用再手動一一複製貼上製作文件,只要輸入一筆或多筆 Google Sheet 資料,文件套版就交給 NoCode 自動化完成吧!
Thumbnail
前一陣子剛從Wordpress(WP)搬來方格子後,除了要稍微習慣一下新的線上編輯器外,另一個體感上比較大的差別之一,大概就是文章發表後的社群分享功能了吧,不過方格子這裡的分享功能,好像還是有點⋯
Thumbnail
前一陣子剛從Wordpress(WP)搬來方格子後,除了要稍微習慣一下新的線上編輯器外,另一個體感上比較大的差別之一,大概就是文章發表後的社群分享功能了吧,不過方格子這裡的分享功能,好像還是有點⋯
追蹤感興趣的內容從 Google News 追蹤更多 vocus 的最新精選內容追蹤 Google News