8 Common Usability Testing Methods in User-Centered Design

更新於 發佈於 閱讀時間約 31 分鐘


raw-image


When designing a new product or feature, it’s crucial to ensure usability and user-friendliness throughout its lifecycle. Although a product may appear ideal theoretically, real-world usage often reveals necessary adjustments. This is why incorporating usability testing methods is essential in effective product design. 

Usability testing involves observing real users interacting with your product. This allows you to identify friction points and refine your designs for a seamless user experience. By using these methods—whether for an app, website, or physical product—you can gain valuable insights into user behavior, preferences, and challenges.

There are various types of usability testing, each suited to different goals and situations. To provide clarity, usability tests are commonly grouped into three main types:

  • Qualitative vs. Quantitative
  • Moderated vs. Unmoderated
  • Remote vs. In-Person

In this article, we’ll focus on organizing Usability Testing Methods into 4 clear categories based on two key types: Moderated vs. Unmoderated and Remote vs. In-Person. This approach will make it easier for you to understand and select the right method to evaluate and improve your product design.

Category 1: Moderated + In-person usability testing methods

Moderated In-Person tests involve a facilitator guiding participants as they complete tasks on a website/app in a physical setting. This method allows for direct observation and interaction, enabling immediate feedback and deeper insights into user behavior and challenges in a controlled environment.

1. Lab usability testing


raw-image


Lab usability testing is conducted in a specially designed testing lab, where participants complete assigned tasks on computers, mobile devices, or other products. At the same time, a trained moderator observes their actions and asks follow-up questions.

When to Use: Lab usability testing is perfect for conducting controlled comparisons, analyzing user interactions in a consistent environment, and pinpointing specific usability issues. For example, it’s helpful to compare two checkout processes on an e-commerce site to determine which one offers a more user-friendly experience.

Pros:

  • High level of control over test conditions.
  • Helps compare user behavior across various design versions for better optimization.
  • Provides rich, in-depth insights into user actions and challenges.

Cons:

  • Expensive and resource-intensive.
  • Limited to a small group of participants (usually 8–10 per round), which may not represent the general user population.
  • A controlled environment may not always reflect real-world use.

2. Guerrilla usability testing

Guerrilla usability testing involves quick, informal tests in public spaces like coffee shops, malls, or airports. Participants are chosen at random and asked to complete a simple usability task, often in exchange for a gift card or other incentive.

When to Use: Guerrilla testing is ideal for quickly gathering informal feedback from a diverse audience, such as testing a website’s navigation with passersby at a café to uncover usability issues and gather insights for improvement.

Pros

  • Fast, low-cost data collection.
  • Access to a wide variety of users.
  • Quick insights into fundamental usability issues.

Cons

  • Results may be based on personal experiences and need more detailed information.
  • Limited control over participant quality and background.
  • Need to conduct follow-up testing for deeper insights.

Category 2: Moderated + Remote usability testing methods

Moderated remote usability tests are conducted using computers or phones with the help of a trained moderator. This way gives access to a diverse pool of testers while still benefiting from the moderator’s expertise and ability to delve into specific insights.

 3. Phone/video interviews

In a phone usability test, a moderator gives verbal instructions to participants as they complete tasks on their computer while feedback is gathered and the user's actions are recorded remotely. 

When to Use: Phone interviews are useful for conducting usability testing of websites or apps, especially when you need detailed, qualitative insights from users across various locations. For example, they can be used to test a new online banking site’s complex account setup process, allowing users to share their thoughts and identify any usability issues in real-time.

Pros

  • Economical for testing across various geographic locations.
  • Facilitates verbal feedback and a deeper understanding of user thought processes.
  • Efficient for collecting a large amount of data in a short time.

Cons

  • Limited visual observation compared to in-person methods.
  • Participants clearly express their thoughts, as any difficulty in communicating may lead to missing important feedback on usability issues.

 4. Card sorting


raw-image


Card sorting is a usability testing method used to understand how users categorize and organize information. Participants are given virtual or physical cards, each representing a concept, item, or piece of content. They then group these cards into categories that make sense to them.

When to Use: Card sorting effectively evaluates website and app navigation by showing how users naturally organize content, making it more intuitive. This method can be used to assess how users group different menu items, such as arranging categories for products on an e-commerce site, ensuring the layout is user-friendly.

Pros

  • Offers insights into natural information categorization.
  • Enhances website structure and navigation.
  • Applicable to both newly developed and existing digital products.

Cons

  • Time-consuming for larger datasets.
  • It may require multiple sessions for comprehensive results.

Category 3: Unmoderated + Remote usability testing methods

Unmoderated usability testing online methods utilize computer programs to observe how users naturally interact with a digital product in their everyday environments. This approach provides valuable insights into user behavior and engagement without the presence of a moderator.

 5. Session recording

Session replays are a method that utilizes software to capture and record the interactions of real (but anonymous) users on a website or app. This includes tracking mouse clicks, movements, and scrolling, allowing you to see how users navigate the site live.

When to Use: Session replays are ideal for spotting major usability issues and areas where users encounter friction, such as when navigating through pages or interacting with forms. For instance, you can use a usability testing tool like Hotjar with session recording to pinpoint where users get stuck during the checkout process at an online clothing store, particularly if they struggle to apply discount codes or enter shipping information, leading them to abandon their cart.

Pros

  • Provides a detailed, visual record of user interactions.
  • Helps identify significant usability issues and areas where users struggle.
  • Useful for improving site functionality and optimizing navigation.

Cons

  • Anonymized data may limit insights into individual user experiences.
  • Larger datasets may require extensive review time.

 6. First-click testing


raw-image

The goal of first-click testing is to see if users can quickly find where they need to go to complete a task. Participants are asked usability test questions like, “Where would you click to buy this product?” and the software tracks where they move their mouse. This setup enables observation of how users interact with the interface and their expectations during navigation.

When to Use: First-click testing is valuable for understanding how intuitive a site’s design and structure are. For instance, you could test where users first click to access a promotional offer on a landing page, which can help inform the ideal placement of important buttons or menus to enhance user experience.

Pros

  • Measures how easily users navigate and make decisions.
  • Helps refine the placement of menus, buttons, and other elements.
  • Provides insights into user expectations and decision-making patterns.

Cons

  • Limited to initial interactions, needing deeper user journey insights.
  • Does not account for user context beyond the first click.

Category 4: Unmoderated + In-person usability testing methods

Unmoderated in-person tests are done in a controlled, physical environment without a person leading the test. By using this, you can gain the benefits of testing in a controlled setting while minimizing the risk of a moderator influencing participants with their questions.

 7. Observation

In this usability testing type, researchers watch quietly without participating, like a ‘fly on the wall,’ as participants follow a set of instructions in a lab. They may step in if someone gets stuck, but otherwise, they observe and take notes. This way, researchers can see how participants react and their body language without any influence from a moderator.

When to Use: Observation is ideal for seeing how users naturally interact with a product without a moderator's influence, helping you understand their navigation on websites and apps. For instance, you can observe how users navigate a travel booking app to search for flights and make reservations, noting any points of confusion or hesitation they may encounter during the process. This method is particularly valuable in usability testing of mobile applications, as it allows you to observe how users engage with mobile interfaces in real-world scenarios.

Pros

  • Provides a natural view of user behavior without moderator interference.
  • Offers insights into body language and non-verbal cues.
  • Effective for evaluating physical interactions and usability in a controlled setting.

Cons

  • It can be time-consuming and requires extensive note-taking.
  • Limited to physical, non-digital interactions. 

 8. Eye-tracking

In eye-tracking tests, researchers use a device that tracks users' eye movements while they interact with a computer. By analyzing where users focus their attention when completing a task, the device creates heatmaps or paths showing where they look the most.

When to Use: Eye-tracking is useful for testing visual design and layout, helping to pinpoint elements that distract or engage users. For example, you might analyze how users view the landing page for a new product, examining which images or text they focus on and which areas they ignore.

Pros

  • Provides detailed insights into visual attention and focus areas.
  • Helps optimize layouts and design elements.
  • Helpful in improving both digital and physical interfaces.

Cons

  • Expensive due to the need for specialized equipment and lab space.
  • Requires a controlled environment, limiting real-world applicability.

Note: All these methods are essential for enhancing the user experience (UX). They help gain valuable insights into how users interact with a product, allowing for improvements that make it more intuitive and user-friendly. This ensures the product meets the needs of its users and provides a seamless experience.

Exciting Year-End Opportunity!

This year-end, don’t miss your chance to claim a FREE UX Audit through our exclusive WinAudit 2024 campaign. Discover actionable insights and uncover key improvement areas in your product using Usability Testing and proven Design Principles to gain a competitive edge in 2025.

Don’t miss out—this opportunity won’t last long! Register now and take the first step toward innovation and success!

Conclusion

Usability testing plays a vital role in crafting user-centered products that deliver exceptional experiences. With various usability testing methods available, you can gather valuable insights (by using Usability Test Tools) into how users interact with your website or app, helping you identify pain points and make necessary improvements from a human-centered design perspective.

If you’re seeking a reliable design agency to conduct a comprehensive usability assessment of your website or app, the design experts at Lollypop Design Studio are here to assist you. As a leading UI/UX design agency, we provide comprehensive product design services—from UX research and UI/UX design to UX audit—ensuring your product delivers seamless user experiences across digital platforms.

Contact us today to discuss a tailored UX audit process designed to meet your unique needs and goals!

留言
avatar-img
留言分享你的想法!
avatar-img
Lollypop Vietnam
1會員
29內容數
We are a dedicated UI/UX design agency in Vietnam, offering design services for clients in South East Asia and everywhere around the globe.
Lollypop Vietnam的其他內容
2025/03/19
In this article, we’ll show you the essentials of guerrilla usability testing tips to help you get the most out of this innovative technique.
Thumbnail
2025/03/19
In this article, we’ll show you the essentials of guerrilla usability testing tips to help you get the most out of this innovative technique.
Thumbnail
2025/03/17
In this blog, we’ve curated a list of top 20 usability testing tools for 2025, catering to every budget.
Thumbnail
2025/03/17
In this blog, we’ve curated a list of top 20 usability testing tools for 2025, catering to every budget.
Thumbnail
2025/03/17
In this blog, we’ll break down the key usability testing metrics to optimize your usability design for better results.
Thumbnail
可能包含敏感內容
2025/03/17
In this blog, we’ll break down the key usability testing metrics to optimize your usability design for better results.
Thumbnail
可能包含敏感內容
看更多
你可能也想看
Thumbnail
沙龍一直是創作與交流的重要空間,這次 vocus 全面改版了沙龍介面,就是為了讓好內容被好好看見! 你可以自由編排你的沙龍首頁版位,新版手機介面也讓每位訪客都能更快找到感興趣的內容、成為你的支持者。 改版完成後可以在社群媒體分享新版面,並標記 @vocus.official⁠ ♥️ ⁠
Thumbnail
沙龍一直是創作與交流的重要空間,這次 vocus 全面改版了沙龍介面,就是為了讓好內容被好好看見! 你可以自由編排你的沙龍首頁版位,新版手機介面也讓每位訪客都能更快找到感興趣的內容、成為你的支持者。 改版完成後可以在社群媒體分享新版面,並標記 @vocus.official⁠ ♥️ ⁠
Thumbnail
每年4月、5月都是最多稅要繳的月份,當然大部份的人都是有機會繳到「綜合所得稅」,只是相當相當多人還不知道,原來繳給政府的稅!可以透過一些有活動的銀行信用卡或電子支付來繳,從繳費中賺一點點小確幸!就是賺個1%~2%大家也是很開心的,因為你們把沒回饋變成有回饋,就是用卡的最高境界 所得稅線上申報
Thumbnail
每年4月、5月都是最多稅要繳的月份,當然大部份的人都是有機會繳到「綜合所得稅」,只是相當相當多人還不知道,原來繳給政府的稅!可以透過一些有活動的銀行信用卡或電子支付來繳,從繳費中賺一點點小確幸!就是賺個1%~2%大家也是很開心的,因為你們把沒回饋變成有回饋,就是用卡的最高境界 所得稅線上申報
Thumbnail
CSS Grid Layout(網格佈局)是一種二維布局系統,比 Flexbox 更適合複雜的頁面佈局,特別是在設計網格化的內容區塊時。 本節我們將實作一個活動流程表,讓讀者了解如何實際使用,啟發 Grid 佈局的基礎使用能力。
Thumbnail
CSS Grid Layout(網格佈局)是一種二維布局系統,比 Flexbox 更適合複雜的頁面佈局,特別是在設計網格化的內容區塊時。 本節我們將實作一個活動流程表,讓讀者了解如何實際使用,啟發 Grid 佈局的基礎使用能力。
Thumbnail
近期在做電商開店平台的後台系統,開始瞭解到「效率型產品」的定位,如何讓使用者更快、更順利地完成一項任務?如何快速抓到使用者的 Jobs-to-be-done?都是產品經理在規劃功能前要先蒐集的資訊,這篇想記錄打造效率型產品的心得。
Thumbnail
近期在做電商開店平台的後台系統,開始瞭解到「效率型產品」的定位,如何讓使用者更快、更順利地完成一項任務?如何快速抓到使用者的 Jobs-to-be-done?都是產品經理在規劃功能前要先蒐集的資訊,這篇想記錄打造效率型產品的心得。
Thumbnail
本篇文章介紹如何使用Figma設計出高效的表單,適合各類設計師。文章內容包括2025最新UX/UI設計趨勢及實用技巧,並提供完整的教學視頻。學習重點包括介面熟悉度、色彩搭配、設計整體感以及對齊的重要性,助你提升設計效率和用戶體驗。立即訂閱頻道掌握未來設計技能!
Thumbnail
本篇文章介紹如何使用Figma設計出高效的表單,適合各類設計師。文章內容包括2025最新UX/UI設計趨勢及實用技巧,並提供完整的教學視頻。學習重點包括介面熟悉度、色彩搭配、設計整體感以及對齊的重要性,助你提升設計效率和用戶體驗。立即訂閱頻道掌握未來設計技能!
Thumbnail
為了確保產品順利開發完成並上線,產品經理需要擁有自己的一套原則/產品思維,包括需求分類、用戶體驗、問題導向、數據驅動等,才能讓讓產品團隊更有效地執行項目、降地風險,最終交付解決用戶需求且具有競爭力的產品。
Thumbnail
為了確保產品順利開發完成並上線,產品經理需要擁有自己的一套原則/產品思維,包括需求分類、用戶體驗、問題導向、數據驅動等,才能讓讓產品團隊更有效地執行項目、降地風險,最終交付解決用戶需求且具有競爭力的產品。
Thumbnail
在UI/UX設計的過程中,定義問題往往是最具挑戰性的部分。設計師需要理解使用者的需求、期望和行為,並將這些理解轉化為實際的設計解決方案。
Thumbnail
在UI/UX設計的過程中,定義問題往往是最具挑戰性的部分。設計師需要理解使用者的需求、期望和行為,並將這些理解轉化為實際的設計解決方案。
Thumbnail
** 3C機構設計爸版權所有 ©️ ** 在工作中,我們會學到很多的管理手法、很多的分析技巧,在業界中所使用的檢討報告8D、RCCA、5C report,FA,通常是在產品的設計或品質發生問題之後所被要求要寫的報告,內容不外乎是要描述事件、分析、原因、庫存狀態、產品狀態、改善對策….等等,在這些報告
Thumbnail
** 3C機構設計爸版權所有 ©️ ** 在工作中,我們會學到很多的管理手法、很多的分析技巧,在業界中所使用的檢討報告8D、RCCA、5C report,FA,通常是在產品的設計或品質發生問題之後所被要求要寫的報告,內容不外乎是要描述事件、分析、原因、庫存狀態、產品狀態、改善對策….等等,在這些報告
Thumbnail
Today I mainly talk about user interviews, and maybe I will talk about interview techniques that persuade people to use them in the future.
Thumbnail
Today I mainly talk about user interviews, and maybe I will talk about interview techniques that persuade people to use them in the future.
Thumbnail
MCDM-Multi-criteria decision-making 在學術上已經運用多年 我們將要導入在企業中,讓企業藉由這個方法,提升競爭力 目前多準則決策可解決及協助企業的方向如下 1. 企業問題改善與分析 2. 供應商管理與決策 3. 商品選擇 4. 促銷方案評估 7. 專案分析及解決
Thumbnail
MCDM-Multi-criteria decision-making 在學術上已經運用多年 我們將要導入在企業中,讓企業藉由這個方法,提升競爭力 目前多準則決策可解決及協助企業的方向如下 1. 企業問題改善與分析 2. 供應商管理與決策 3. 商品選擇 4. 促銷方案評估 7. 專案分析及解決
Thumbnail
無論是參與面試或釐清需求,系統設計常常令人感到困惑,不知如何進行。 我想,原因大概有兩種。 首先,不同領域的系統通常都有不同的設計要素,如何找出這些要素進行提問? 其次,即便提出疑問找出重點,接下來要如何針對這些要素進行高層設計或規劃? 《系統設計面試指南》對於系統設計的初步規劃或高層結構提供合適的
Thumbnail
無論是參與面試或釐清需求,系統設計常常令人感到困惑,不知如何進行。 我想,原因大概有兩種。 首先,不同領域的系統通常都有不同的設計要素,如何找出這些要素進行提問? 其次,即便提出疑問找出重點,接下來要如何針對這些要素進行高層設計或規劃? 《系統設計面試指南》對於系統設計的初步規劃或高層結構提供合適的
Thumbnail
最近收到了一封學生的信,詢問在職場中UI Designer是什麼?想在公司建立一套基本的流程,這張圖片應該許多人都看過,裡頭有很多專業的名詞,以及像金字一樣往上堆疊的順序,在討論工作流程前,我們一樣先來了解每個詞彙代表什麼、以及它存在的目的是什麼。 Us
Thumbnail
最近收到了一封學生的信,詢問在職場中UI Designer是什麼?想在公司建立一套基本的流程,這張圖片應該許多人都看過,裡頭有很多專業的名詞,以及像金字一樣往上堆疊的順序,在討論工作流程前,我們一樣先來了解每個詞彙代表什麼、以及它存在的目的是什麼。 Us
追蹤感興趣的內容從 Google News 追蹤更多 vocus 的最新精選內容追蹤 Google News